HfS Network

Category Archives: Financial Services Sourcing Strategies

Can HPE + CSC dominate the digital underbelly, or has that ship sailed?

June 19, 2016 | Phil Fersht
Digital Underbelly

Just stare at that digital underbelly... there's a lot of work needed down there!

When the news broke last month about the second largest IT services merger of all time (after the 2008 HP-EDS whopper), the reaction among the services cognoscenti was - and has continued to be - one of confusion.  Big services mergers have just not done very well over the years. HP/EDS was a culture clash of immense proportions - and occurred right before the great recession, while other mergers, like Dell's acquisition of Perot, has resulted in the old Perot business being flipped over to NTT Data at a significant loss, and the Xerox/ACS merger has been shaken up and spun off and needs a major reinvention under new CEO Ashok Vemuri to get the company back on track.  Meanwhile, Capgemini and IGATE are still figuring out the best pieces of each other to mesh together, while not taking their eye off the ball, during the services industries' most cut-throat transition phase.

We heard HPE CEO, Meg Whitman, excitedly address the firm’s key clients and industry analysts at HP’s recent Discover event in Las Vegas, with an obsessive focus on “digital transformation” and the impending impact of “digital disruption”.  However, the real opportunity for HPE isn’t really in the design of digital business models for clients, it’s the enablement of them – it’s the provision of the agile “digital underbelly” to make digital change really happen for enterprises.

It's easy to be cynical about legacy IT services, but there's an awful lot of it to scrap over as enterprises are forced to fix their plumbing

Digesting the merger of these two struggling services giants has resulted in more rumination than most, considering the timing, sheer scale, transitional uncertain market and motivation. This is not a time when most traditional service providers are looking to add more global delivery scale to already large foundations – most are trying to slim down their delivery armies and sales forces,

Read More »

Posted in: Analytics and Big DataBusiness Process Outsourcing (BPO)Buyers' Sourcing Best Practices



Meet the Dinamo driving TCS' business process services impressive growth

June 03, 2016 | Phil Fersht
Dinanath (Dina) Kholkar is Vice President and Global Head of BPS at Tata Consultancy Services

Dinanath (Dina) Kholkar is Global Head of Business Process Services at Tata Consultancy Services

As we endlessly debate the future of the global IT service delivery in the wake of advances in automation, digital disruption and the ability to maintain double digit growth rates, one area that has steadfastly kept to respectable growth and improved delivery confidence is our beloved business process outsourcing services.

In fact, we are about to reveal to all of you that the growth in Indian-heritage BPO has been consistently out-performing IT services over the last year.  Why?  Because BPO is several years behind IT in terms of widespread adoption, but is now coming to the forefront as processes can be better-enabled by cloud platforms and maturing global delivery models.

In this vein, I thought it timely to interview Dina Kholkar, TCS' global head of BPS, who has helped steer his division to $1.9 billion at a 6% growth clip... making BPS now represent 12% of the total TCS business...

Phil Fersht, CEO and Chief Analyst, HfS: Good evening, Dina. It's great to have you on HfS for the first time. You've been one of the best kept secrets behind the exciting growth in the Business Process Services (BPO) team at TCS. Maybe you can share a little bit about yourself, your own background and how you ended up leading the highest-growth division in TCS today.

Dinanath (Dina) Kholkar, Vice President and Global Head of BPS at Tata Consultancy Services:  Sure, Phil. I've been at TCS for a very long time. This is my 27th year in TCS! I started in 1990 as part of the IT business. I managed a few IT projects, went on to manage accounts across different geographies, different types of roles. The longest stint I had was in the capital markets area. I also spent a few years in TCS’ R&D unit, predominantly focusing on data warehousing and data mining. Those were the years when data had started becoming a focus in many organizations. I did have a stint in operations when I was managing customers, but I never really managed the business of running operations until I got the opportunity to manage e-Serve, which TCS had acquired from Citibank. After a few years, when it was integrated into TCS, I took on the role of the overall head of the TCS BPS business. So we’ve had quite an exciting and an interesting journey, a journey filled with lot of learning and a lot of customers we’ve been able to positively impact over the years. And I feel quite proud about the type of opportunities that I have gotten and the way I have delivered on the objectives that TCS has laid out for itself.

Phil: So what can you share with us then about the secret sauce at TCS? What is it that makes you guys really tick?

Dina: One thing which I have always seen probably over multiple generations—and all three CEO leaders of TCS—really strikes me is the customer centricity. We go the distance, which means we do whatever we need to do for the customer. We do the right things and ensure that we are taking care of the customer’s business, bringing all we have as an organization to solve problems that the customer has. I think that customer centricity is paramount in the organization. I think we also

Read More »

Posted in: Analytics and Big DataBusiness Process Outsourcing (BPO)Design Thinking



Accenture, Cognizant, EXL, Genpact, IBM, Infosys and TCS Top the Winners Circle for BFS Analytics

April 04, 2016 | Phil Fersht

The BFS industry is completely dependant on data and analytics and the services to provide these analytics are critical. These services enable analytics data preparation and management, routine business intelligence reporting and dashboarding, advanced analytics modeling and ongoing decision-making for industry-specific use cases, including customer and marketing analytics, fraud, risk and compliance, and portfolio analytics.

To this end, we're excited to announce the release of our latest Blueprint Report--this one on BFS Analytics Services, authored by HfS Research Director Reetika Joshi's exhaustive research to arrive at this comprehensive view of the market. So let's get an up-close view from Reetika on the Blueprint Report:

Click to Enlarge

Click to Enlarge

Reetika, why have we undertaken an HfS Blueprint on analytics services specifically in banking and financial services?

The BFS industry is heavily reliant on the use of data, and yet the potential for embedding analytics-driven insights into operations is still far greater than adoption. The last few years have seen their focus on risk analytics intensify as regulatory changes and government scrutiny continue to mount. Along with balancing this growing compliance work, banks have also found a renewed interest in customer analytics to orient their growth initiatives. Most banks are not set up to meet digital consumer needs and are now embarking on digital transformation, powered by customer and marketing analytics.

Major banks and financial institutions are once again focusing on the next generation of analytics models, tools, and skillsets. We see demand from BFS clients across fraud, risk and compliance, AML/KYC, and customer and marketing analytics. Enterprise buyers in this industry are either unable to find the talent they need, for areas like specialized fraud, risk and compliance, or technology platform expertise, or are unable to afford it at the level of scale needed today—leading us to undertake this Blueprint to understand market direction. We see BFS clients trying to balance and complement their internal analytics teams with the global talent access that some service providers can bring them.

Report author Reetika Joshi, HfS Research Director (click for bio).

Report author Reetika Joshi, HfS Research Director (click for bio).

So how would you describe the current state of BFS analytics services?

For most service providers, big data and analytics services are the fastest-growing businesses in their portfolios, with significant revenues coming from BFS clients. This is due to the growing adoption of data-driven decision making within different parts of the enterprise for BFS buyers, and the need for more analytical support than internal staff can support.

Service providers have doubled down on BFS verticalization in their analytics portfolios, turning initial work with clients for analytics modeling and reporting into portfolios of pre-packaged industry-specific use cases and catalogues. As service buyers consistently stress the need for domain expertise from service providers, we see service providers strengthening industry training programs and hiring professionals from BFS industry backgrounds to increase contextual understanding and allowing for more meaningful analysis. We see the types of BFS analytics solutions changing today, with the next level of analytics use case development. BFS analytics services buyers seek the following:

  • The application of cross-vertical learnings to banking, especially from other consumer-facing industries that have progressed in customer experience analytics (e.g., from telecom to retail banking)
  • The incorporation of newer sources of data into existing analytical models to gain new insights into fraud, risk, and marketing (e.g., sensors, geolocation mobile data, and web and social data)
  • The exploration of modern business intelligence and reporting applications and tools, big data infrastructure, and advanced analytics platforms (e.g., cloud-based data warehousing, the mobile delivery of reports, and insights)

Read More »

Posted in: Analytics and Big DataBusiness Process Outsourcing (BPO)Buyers' Sourcing Best Practices



HfS is back in Cambridge University for another no-cheese bake off of services leaders

December 21, 2015 | Phil Fersht

The Event: The European HfS Service Leaders Summit

The Date: 21-22nd March 2016 (click for details)

The Venue: Gonville & Caius College Cambridge

The Theme:  Avoiding the Race to Irrelevance

To Apply for a Seat / lead a session (buyers only):  Email us here

This promises to be another UK style "throw the kitchen sink at everything crappy about our service industry"

We're back at Gonville & Caius College, Cambridge this Spring (Click to learn more)

We're back at Gonville & Caius College, Cambridge this Spring (Click to learn more)

Join these core discussions where we'll finally address these issues:

The Race to Irrelevance: Are we on a race to the bottom, or are we genuinely in the midst of change: Are service providers really selling what service buyers actually need?
Europeans v Americans: Who’s outsourcing smarter and where can we improve to get to the As-a-Service Enterprise?
Demystifying all that Robo Hype: What is the realistic place for a Robotic Process Automation strategy inside the enterprise - and what should Service providers be doing to support it?
Digital Transformation: It's really all about the business, stupid!
Beyond the Transition: How can service buyers and providers really share their risks to achieve longer-term gains?
Ending the Master/Slave Model: Can service buyers and providers leverage "Design Thinking" to fashion a collaborative relationship with a common purpose, common values and jointly desired outcomes?
Getting beyond the Paperwork: What does it really take, in today's environment, to execute and manage a meaningful, effective and lasting contract?
Getting past that "outsourcing career track" discussion: Is the outsourcing "profession" now part of a broader management capability?
The Message we have to Send Back to the Industry: How can we fix this industry to deliver the As-a-Service Enterprise?

Service buyers email us here to apply for your seat...

None of that famous Cambridge cheese, honest!

None of that famous Cambridge cheese, honest!

Posted in: Buyers' Sourcing Best PracticesCaptives and Shared Services StrategiesDesign Thinking



The HfS 2016 Blueprint Research Agenda ...at your service

November 22, 2015 | Phil Fersht

2016 will mark our seventh year as an analyst firm and will be our most expansive as we tackle many emerging areas and industries.  Yes, we have come an awfully long way since the days people thought we "only covered BPO":

Click to Enlarge

Click to Enlarge

The analyst industry's most ambitious 2016 research agenda tackles the continuum from legacy operations to the As-a-Service Enterprise across talent, technology and process

Earlier in 2014, we introduced to the world the concept of the As-a-Service Economy and how it is fundamentally impacting how business and IT services have to be fashioned, solutioned and delivered. Enterprise service buyers and providers have little choice but to evolve how they manage their services, or face extinction.

This means both parties need to make genuine investments in their underlying process architectures, reorient their talent capabilities and make some short-to-medium term sacrifices in their financial models to remain viable in the As-a-Service Economy. The same issues apply to sourcing advisors and analysts that face increasing irrelevance if they fail to adjust to the shifting demands of what it means to be an “As-a-Service Enterprise” in this new economy.

The legacy model of IT and business services sales and delivery that has dominated the industry for decades has rapidly become obsolete in our increasingly digital world, where speed, agility, flexibility and re-invention are no longer optional, but core characteristics for the success of any As-a-Service Enterprise.

For HfS, As-a-Service is about continuous progression, where enterprises do not pause at a status quo state. Instead they are continually exploring better ways to automate processes, access rapid meaningful data, and advance self-learning capabilities in a secure, trusted environment.

Our thinking about the Ideals of the As-a-Service Enterprise also has progressed this year. We now segment the ideals into Change Management Ideals and Solution Ideals that intermingle and build upon each other on the journey to the As-a-Service Enterprise. This journey will require significant change management, and through the course of 2015, we have seen encouraging examples of that throughout the industry, especially with efforts to simplify and automate increasingly unwieldy legacy operations and technology.

We could write and talk for hours about the unwillingness of enterprises to change the status quo to achieve better results. But ultimately it all boils down to the leadership of the enterprise having the appetite to go out and find a trusted partner that is motivated to share the risks of this transition within a financial model that works for all parties. Middle management will always resist anything that doesn’t pay them more, make them happier and more excited, or more motivated to perform. The only way forward to achieve genuine plug-and-play digital business solutions is for service providers and enterprises buyers to embrace real design thinking concepts and work together continuously in a much more collaborative and transparent fashion. This means they need to invest in talent, in training, in change fundamentals—and ultimately in solution fundamentals.

The Ideals of the As-a-Service Enterprise explained

In sharing our thinking on the Ideals of the As-a-Service Enterprise through countless client strategy sessions, industry-wide webinars and briefings this year, we have had the chance to test these Ideals with industry stakeholders to understand their relevance and practical applications.

What came out from these sessions was that the Ideals fell into two key themes: Change Management Ideals and Solution Ideals. In many cases enterprises approach these ideals sequentially.

Click to Enlarge

Click to Enlarge

To move toward the As-a-Service Enterprise, it is beneficial to begin with a willingness to write off the legacy technology and operations and with that adopt Design Thinking as a way to look at business challenges and opportunities with a fresh perspective. Then an enterprise can orient governance and relationships toward building service solutions with the optimum capabilities,

Read More »

Posted in: Analytics and Big DataBusiness Process Outsourcing (BPO)Buyers' Sourcing Best Practices



Provider, provider on the wall, who's delivering Trust for Digital?

October 18, 2015 | Phil Fersht

Anyone who knows me well has seen how hard we've been pressing the importance of security and trust in a global services delivery environment, since we founded HfS.

In short, we're moving into a world where reactive fixes to security breaches is a sure-fire recipe for disaster.  Savvy enterprises simply have to deploy proactive, holistic management practices of their data flows across systems, people and processes.  What's more, with all these new investments going into digital technology, SaaS platforms, global outsourcing initiatives and automation bots, the risks out there with our data flying all around the place - and the trust in people needed to manage these risks - is second to none.

So who better than an analyst legend of the networking and computing boom era, the founder of analyst firm Current Analysis himself, and now a year-long member of the HfS team, Fred McClimans, to have a serious deep dive into what we are calling... Trust-as-a-Service:

Click to Enlarge

Click to Enlarge

So Fred, why a Blueprint on security, or perhaps the better question, why trust as a Blueprint topic?

The transformation from an analog to a digital economy has been profound, giving rise to a whole new wave of business and economic models that place the consumer first and corporate assets online. This is a huge shift from the legacy models where brands controlled the message, consumers ate what was available, and managing risk meant not much more than a solid business plan, a line of credit, and Master locks on the front and back doors. That game ended a long time ago.

With most, if not all, corporate data now available online, and a massive consumer-driven omnichannel engagement model, we’ve literally given competitors and “evil-doers” a map of where

Read More »

Posted in: Analytics and Big DataBusiness Process Outsourcing (BPO)Cloud Computing



Accenture, Wipro, TCS and ISGN make the Winner's Circle for Mortgage Services BPO

May 20, 2014 | Phil Fersht

The residential mortgage services market is one of the most established and competitive segments of the global BPO industry. Most of the major service providers have been in this market for a considerable time providing services across the process chain of mortgage origination, mortgage servicing and the (sadly more significant these days) area of loan default and foreclosure management.

It used to be that most service providers were simply providing domestic or offshored labor to augment the capacity needs of the large lenders, but that old operating model is being changed as a result of the consequences of what happened to our global economies post 2008 - and especially in the US.  Whereas before the crash the entire mortgage industry was going through such a “gold rush” that volume took precedence above all else, now, as a result of increased regulations and reduced volumes that have driven up the cost of completing a loan origination, the focus is elsewhere.

Today, this is an industry looking closely at the processes and technologies that underlie the business and turning to industry savvy service providers which can provide cost effective, compliant delivery that increasingly includes a significant component of sourced technology solutions as well. This mature market is changing and, as a result, so too is the roster of BPO service providers who are meeting those evolving client needs. So let’s take a closer look at the innovation and execution capabilities of the leading service mortgage services BPO providers:

Click to Enlarge

HfS has evaluated the innovation and execution capabilities of service providers catering to the origination, servicing and default/foreclosure management processes of residential mortgage lenders.  We asked our EVP of Research, Charles Sutherland, who led this blueprint initiative, to share some of his insights arising from this Blueprint Report.

Charles, what are some of the key challenges facing lenders today?

This is a market segment undergoing a profound level of change.  First, of all there is a dramatic fall in customer demand for new loans as post-crash engine of refinanced loans is coming to an end.   Second, is the rise in the overall costs of originating a loan, which are now up several

Read More »

Posted in: Analytics and Big DataBusiness Process Outsourcing (BPO)Buyers' Sourcing Best Practices



Capgemini's new BPO General rocks up: Chris Stancombe

May 11, 2014 | Phil Fersht

We should change the image of the industry, there are fantastic opportunities for people who want to get involved and we should do a better job of attracting talent

- Chris Stancombe, Capgemini, May 2014

Christopher Stancombe is Chief Executive Officer, BPO strategic business unit, Capgemini

One of the main features of the BPO industry since the Great Recession has been the emergence of several providers with a progressive outlook, which are now driving the market. One of those has been Capgemini, which has captured third spot in market share and made the Winner's Circle for finance and accounting (F&A) BPO.

In addition, the BPO service line has been promoted to a tier one delivery unit for the global Capgemini organization, giving the division added strategic focus and resources. Great credit has to be given to Hubert Giraud who has overseen the growth of the BPO business and has now been moved upstairs to lead HR and transformation of the whole Capgemini company - clearly great recognition of his success leading and growing the most people-centric business unit for the firm.

Filling his shoes has been one of the mainstays of the BPO business, quietly asserting his practical style and approach to operations and global services. Since joining Capgemini in 2005, Christopher Stancombe has overseen the expansion, growth and maturity of the Capgemini F&A BPO business, before advancing to the COO role for the whole BPO division last year and then taking on the full CEO role from Hubert this year.

For those of you who don't know Chris so well, he actually started his professional life as a geophysicist and even ran an African engineering business before venturing into the world global service provision. He's a straight-talking, pragmatic chap who likes to get to the point... so without further ado...

Phil Fersht, CEO, HfS Research: Good afternoon, Chris, and welcome back to HfS. I think it's been three years since we last had you on here (see interview). So I imagine quite a lot has changed. Can you just tell me what you've been up to? How have the last three years fared?

Chris Stancombe, CEO, BPO Division, Capgemini: Thanks Phil, it's a pleasure to speak with you again. This year we are celebrating our ten year anniversary of BPO at Capgemini and I've been here for nine of those now. So it has been a good time for reflection. People always say it, but the pace of change is incredible. Over the last three years I've been very focused on the delivery side as

Read More »

Posted in: Business Process Outsourcing (BPO)Cloud ComputingFinance & Accounting BPO



This week on the HfS Podcast: Who made it into the Insurance BPO Winner's Circle?

March 25, 2014 | Phil Fersht

Reetika Joshi is HfS Research Director, BPO and Analytics Strategies (click for bio)

On this edition of the HfS Podcast, Mark Reed-Edwards talks with Reetika Joshi, Research Director, BPO & Analytics Strategies at HfS.

Reetika recently published the HfS Blueprint Report: Insurance BPO, which evaluated the innovation and execution capabilities of service providers in life and annuities, property and casualty, and other segments.

In the podcast, we examine the following questions: What data is behind the report? What are the key highlights from the report? Which providers made it into the Winner’s Circle? Which ones were close? What does it take to make it into the Winner's Circle? Listen below for answers to those and other questions.


Posted in: Business Process Outsourcing (BPO)Financial Services Sourcing StrategiesKnowledge Process Outsourcing & Analytics



The Progressive BPO Train has left the Station - is IBM on it?

March 10, 2014 | Phil Fersht

Since the divestment of its voice business to Concentrix, IBM’s medium-term strategy with its BPO business lines has been squarely under the microscope.

From our standpoint at HfS, it's abundantly clear that an ambitious 49% of enterprise BPO clients are shifting towards a two-pronged requirement of both operational and transformational (what HfS terms as “Progressive”) service needs. With this in mind, is Ginni Rommety's revamped IBM corporate strategy geared towards the firm's long-term success as a BPO provider?

IBM has been evaluating areas of its business where it may be losing its competitive edge and/or profit margins are simply getting too squeezed, which explains its other recent sell-off of its x86 server business to Lenovo. Two years into the job, it is clear that Ginni is focusing on high-margin cloud software, analytics and services, as opposed to commodity computing and storage. So if the cheap, low-margin businesses are becoming no-goers for the firm, where does this leave their BPO business, which has grown up on the transactional, highly scaled and fungible, low-wage employee model?

The winning BPO providers in today’s market are those which have proven credentials to run standard business services at competitive prices, with the business transformation, analytical and IT enablement capability to take ambitious clients to new thresholds of value.  Not dissimilar to the development of the IT outsourcing business over the past two decades, the capability to run the standard operations for clients has become commoditized at increasingly low-margins, while the higher margin work lies with the integration and consulting areas, tied to those outsourced operations.

However, the major distinction between BPO and ITO that we, at HfS, are seeing with maturing BPO delivery is that it simply is not as easy to separate the “transactional” from the “higher value, progressive activities”.  Simply put, if you outsource your cash apps, invoice processing, collections and general ledger consolidation operations to one provider, it is nigh-on impossible to bring in another provider to run financial planning and analysis, auditing, treasury, risk compliance activities, if that second provider does not have an institutional knowledge of your ground-up bread and butter processes.

Can providers like IBM prosper in BPO if they sell-off their lower-margin operation services?

In essence, the industry shift from “Lights-on” to “Progressive” Outsourcing requires a two-pronged delivery approach from providers:  transactional process services and higher-value transformation services. At HfS, we believe that this shift from a world of “Lights-on Outsourcing” to one of “Progressive Outsourcing” entails a massive degree of change for both clients and service providers if this is to be successful.  So many of the elements of Progressive Outsourcing are so significantly different from where this marketplace has been languishing for the last twenty years, there is, in essence, a chasm to cross in terms of the level of change management needed to discard legacy enterprise practices that are still so entrenched in so many organizations. The following exhibit shows the before and after picture for outsourcing buyers and providers faced with the BPO chasm:

Click to Enlarge

Hence, the big question for IBM is whether the firm will continue to invest in its "Lights On" BPO business lines in order to profit from the higher value fruits on offer with the "Progressive" business and IT needs of maturing BPO clients.  With its key top tier BPO rivals, namely Accenture, Capgemini and Genpact, clearly moving along this two-pronged path of operational and transformational delivery, IBM needs to demonstrate a similar commitment to the BPO industry.

Clearly, IBM wants to deliver cloud software, consulting and integration services in HR, finance, supply chain and marketing areas where it can reap the rewards of the tastier margins, but HfS is concerned those incumbent providers of the BPO operations will get first bite at the higher-margin

Read More »

Posted in: Analytics and Big DataBusiness Process Outsourcing (BPO)Cloud Computing