The colossus Cloud Business Services study we just conducted, in conjunction with the Outsourcing Unit at the London School of Economics, has served up some contrasting concerns that business executives are having versus their IT counterparts: Cloud’s potential impact on work culture versus its impact on the value of the today’s IT department.
Essentially, two-thirds of business executives have expressed concern over the impact Cloud business services could have on the speed by which they could be driven to operate in virtual environments. Moreover, a similar number expressed concerns over Cloud impeding their ability to collaborate with other businesses.
Conversely, IT executives are hugely worried (80%) by the potential for Cloud providers to exploit customers, but contradict these fears by also worrying about competitors leveraging Cloud to steal competitive advantage from them:
The bottom-line: when the business execs look at Cloud, they sense a major cultural change in the way they work, while IT executives are terrified by the potential curtailment of their value as the technology-enabler of core business processes.
The fact that the IT side of the house recognizes the competitive advantages Cloud can give business (see Part I), creates a massive challenge to the CIO today: how can their IT department become a vehicle for helping their organization find competitive value from Cloud. Because if the CIO fails to deliver this value, the business side will be forced to look at alternative avenues. We’ll talk about the business transformation implications of Cloud shortly. Stay tuned for more…
Posted in : Cloud Computing, IT Outsourcing / IT Services, SaaS, PaaS, IaaS and BPaaS, Sourcing Best Practises, sourcing-change, the-industry-speaks
Rather than be in doubt, based on personal opinion or paradigm shift, maybe a controlled limited test case experiment might be in order. Maybe the cloud needs to move from concept to confirmation/non-confirmation. Just a thought.
Excellent topic on the cloud. I’m discovering that both business and IT executives are not only sensing but are actively adopting the use of cloud-based solutions in conjunction with their ERP investments to improve working capital and reduce IT spend. For example, cloud applications for Credit-to-Cash optimization will leverage existing ERP investments and present the data through the lens of the individual user. And, rather than IT scheduling costly ERP “customizations” to meet changing business requirements, the cloud application is “configured” by the business users to meet specific and often time-sensitive needs without impacting the ERP system of record. In this context, cloud applications + ERP are enabling a new nimbleness for the business, will not consume scarce IT resources and will provide a significantly lower TCO.
Fear is good across both the parties Business and IT. This will ensure controlled progression towards cloud based collaboration rather than adhoc approach. Once Progressive elaboration is done over cloud most of the fears would get controlled and innovative approaches will be found for competition fears and it is high time IT vendors/companies look at business solutions rather than a technological approach.
[…] (Cross-posted @ Horses for Sources) […]
Thanks for sharing the findings on this hot topic, and this looks to be very balanced and excellent reflection of organizations view in terms of anxiety and hope from the cloud business services. While business is more upbeat about cloud as an alternative IT service model the technology investments will certainly need to provide a better value in terms of outcomes coupled with speed & cost. Agreed with Gary that cloud ncessarily needs to leverage the existing ERP investment and some good innovation is already happening in this area. It will be interesting to note the ‘areas’ where cloud adoption is happening faster based on this study.
[…] Utility, Cloud and Grid Computing An Information Systems Perspective « Good summary of Cloud Computing statistics (though somewhat hyped statistics!) The Industry Speaks about Cloud, Part II: business execs fear its impact on work culture; IT execs doubt their ability to drive competitive advantage November 15, 2010 The Industry Speaks about Cloud, Part II: business execs fear its impact on work culture; IT execs d…. […]
[…] the Outsourcing Unit at the London School of Economics, contrasts many differing views and expectations from business and IT executives about Cloud business services… however, both sides do agree […]
Could be that the implementation of the cloud will strip out some of the mystery of technology, simplifying the organization’s eco-system, and taking power away from the historical (IT) rulers. What a change that would be…