HfS lands second spot in the Analyst Value Index

November 18, 2013 | Phil Fersht

So here we are, staring up at the big shadow of the Borg after four years of ranting and raving about the future of the services industry, collecting data like lunatics and flinging our research over the paywall to anyone who wants to read it.  We've managed to race past 42 unsuspecting purveyors of analytical information (click here to view the full Index results), leaving us with just the one hurdle to jump.  But we'll take second.  Second is good, it's where you can pose as the alternative to numero uno.  It's like winning the silver medal for table tennis at the Olympics - and not being Chinese.  It's like Netflix taking on HBO...

In all seriousness, when analyst observer maestro, Duncan Chapple, and his team at Kea Company went out and surveyed an unprecedented 352 consumers of IT and services research, we thought we'd be happy with an honorable mention, or maybe a "they're quite good at covering outsourcing" pat on the back.  Or even an "innovation" award, which is what you give the little guys who try hard and have great ideas, but ultimately get their asses kicked by the monolith incumbents.  So, you can imagine our surprise when we - somehow - didn't get trampled by the old guard, when the real consumers of research came through and declared out stuff is actually pretty bloody useful, accessible and more valuable than much of the other stuff floating around out there...

Click to Enlarge

Why is this data meaningful?

The respondent depth is more significant than any other analyst firm survey. There were a minimum of 40 respondents commenting on each firm (352 in total took the survey).

Small research firms can out-muscle much larger competitors on trust and quality.  Key categories for formulating the overall scoring were current value, degree of independence, future confidence and share of voice.  We like the fact that boutiques can compete with firms many times their size.  Research quality isn't about how much money a firm makes, or how many bodies are on the ground - it's about getting insights to market quickly and accessibly that are credible and have the confidence of the reader.

Analysts focused on services do well.  Congratulations to some of our services research peers, which also made the top 10.  This reflects well on the amout of focus and diligence we're all placing on the space, and the level of interest out sector has in reading our work.

And, finally, we'd like to give a shout out to Kea Company's Duncan Chapple and Ian Scott for their hard work in developing the Analyst Value Index:

Posted in: Business Process Outsourcing (BPO)Cloud ComputingHfSResearch.com Homepage

Never Miss A Story

Sign up for the HfS Research newsletter and get the best research delivered to your inbox weekly.




  1. Duncan Chapple
    Posted Nov 18, 2013 06:37 AM | Permalink Reply

    Hi Phil. Thanks for this, and especially for flagging up Ian Scott. I've learnt a lot from working with Ian on the survey this year. Your key points about the meaningfulness of the data are spot on. There are a couple of other points I'd make. One is independence; it's clearly very important to users of analysts services. Second is that analyst forms that follow services are all doing well, and I think that's because of the market, not just the analysts: there's lots of intangibles and analysts in the services sector have different questions and buyers have different needs. The last point is trajectory. HfS did well in the Index, but like NelsonHall and Gartner, it seems to be accelerating.

  2. Purnima Menon
    Posted Nov 18, 2013 06:22 PM | Permalink Reply

    Many Congratulations Phil! This is an awesome achievement!

    Purnima Menon

  3. Hyoun Park
    Posted Nov 18, 2013 10:44 AM | Permalink Reply

    Congratulations, Phil. Your placement is well deserved. HfS are the "analyst's analyst" in many respects for the quality of your work.

  4. Bala Somasundaram
    Posted Nov 18, 2013 01:08 PM | Permalink Reply

    Congratulations Phil!. That's great news!


  5. Paul McCullough
    Posted Nov 18, 2013 06:59 PM | Permalink Reply

    Well done to the HFS team - deserved recognition for all your hard work and great research,


  6. Dan
    Posted Nov 18, 2013 08:47 PM | Permalink Reply

    Way to go HfS! Just one more rung to climb now :)

  7. Mike Withey
    Posted Nov 19, 2013 12:10 AM | Permalink Reply

    Good to see you getting the recognition you deserve at HfS. The 'tell it how it is' Generation Y style with substance is ticking the right boxes it seems. Generation X analysts and advisors take note (especially as we enter budget season) !

  8. George Cairns
    Posted Nov 19, 2013 03:56 AM | Permalink Reply

    Fantastic achievement HFS team!

  9. Chirayu Thakkar
    Posted Nov 19, 2013 01:13 PM | Permalink Reply

    Congratulations Phil!!!

  10. Duke B
    Posted Nov 20, 2013 01:10 AM | Permalink Reply

    Phil awesome!!

  11. Dawn Evans
    Posted Nov 20, 2013 04:21 AM | Permalink Reply

    Congrats Phil, you've worked hard to get here and it shows.

  12. Senthil
    Posted Dec 02, 2013 07:49 PM | Permalink Reply

    Congrats Phil to you and your team! That is a great achievement !

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.